Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Tyler Vincent's avatar

I'm currently reading the controversial Christopher Caldwell's "The Age of Entitlement: America Since the Sixites." I am willing to bet that most of your readers would find a lot of what he says appalling, yet I think everyone would agree that the major event that led to our current climate was the success of the Rush Limbaugh Radio Show. Caldwell said that that was the point where politics stopped being something you practiced in your community. Now, politics was your community.

Roger Ailes put Limbaugh on syndicated TV, and then parlayed the success of that venture into running Ruper Murdock's Fox News, which was wildly successful. MSNBC saw what Fox News was doing and attempted to be a left-wing version of that.

This marked another turning point according to pop-culture writer Chuck Klosterman: people en masse stopped watching the news to get informed of what was going on so they could make up their minds about it- they started watching the news to have their preconceived biases confirmed and comforted.

Throw social media on top of that and you have the current situation. Social media promised to expand the conversation in the global community. Pastor Jason Gudim of the Being Lutheran Podcast noted that what it's actually done is shrink our definition of who our neighbor is, leaving the partaker to build his or her own monastery of like-minded people while looking at everyone else as the other.

I've found myself guilty of that.

Expand full comment
Holly A.J.'s avatar

You are right, that our citizenship in the kingdom of heaven should give us inner peace. But we still live in the world, and our physical bodies still suffer the affects of war and famine and plague. There are Christians in Ukraine, and there are Christians in Gaza and the West Bank and Israel and Lebanon. They cannot escape what the politics of power is doing to their homes, their neighbours, and their families. If our hearts are not wrung by their plight, how can we pray for them fervently? If we do not feel our own vulnerability to the whims of earthly powers, is our trust in God merely complacency?

It is true that Jesus did not deeply concern himself with politics. But his brief interactions with rulers show he was fully alive to the characters of those in power. He calls Herod 'that fox' and refuses to speak a word when he is brought before - he knew Herod had had his chance of repentance when he listened to John the Baptist, and Herod had instead had John executed on a perverted whim. When Jesus interacts with Pilate, his brief replies show he knew he was dealing with a man who was a coward, who would bow to the greatest political pressure put on him from any side. Jesus didn't involve himself himself in politics, no, but he was realistic in dealing with it. He was also broken by the terrible effects of it - he knew Rome would eventually destroy Jersulam, and he wept over that coming destruction, warning those who would listen. Paul also is fully aware of who he deals with. He knows Felix is corrupt, he knows Festus isn't really interested in the truth, he knows Agrippa is an honourable king. The early Christians were fully cognisant of the world in which they lived - their courage and faith was based in real life experience.

The recent serious threats to the stability of the nation into which I was born, Canada, has threatened the security I so long took for granted. I have lived and visited much less stable areas. For over a year, I worked in a country that had a megalomaniac with delusions of grandeur in power and a feared spy network to remove any who so much as criticized him - as a foreigner, I wouldn't have been killed if I expressed criticism but I would have been expelled (this ruler has since been deposed). I have lived in a city in another country which was relatively stable, but yearly demonstrations often turned into riots, so I had to be aware of where the dangerous areas could be at those times. But those dangers seemed slightly less threatening because I always could go home to the land of my birth. But if that secure retreat itself is affected - when threats of economic destabilization for the purposes of annexation are repeatedly leveled at it, then one really does have to dig deeper into one's faith to find the security the outer world no longer offers anywhere.

Expand full comment
46 more comments...

No posts